Tuesday, June 7, 2011
The Characters
Laura: I am a Dutch-Canadian, person with a disability, follower of Jesus Christ, woman, student, teacher, and … so much more. I have lived in the best place on Earth (just outside Victoria, BC :) for most of my (almost) 23 years. I grew up in a loving family and although it wasn’t always easy, we always had enough food to eat and a place to call home. I am aware that I have had many privileges due in part to my economic position and my appearance (at a glance I look like an ‘average’ white, able-bodied woman). I am on a journey discovering how to learn and teach across differences and from differences, and how I can respect all the teachers and learners around me.
Michele: I was born in Vancouver, British Columbia to immigrant parents. I self-identify myself as being Chinese-Japanese-Canadian. I was very fortunate to have grown up in a middle class family in a city called Coquitlam. About to turn 25, I spent the last 6 years completing a B.A. in history and am now about to finish my BSW. I currently live with my partner in beautiful Victoria, BC. We are both serving reservists with the Canadian Navy. In addition, I am also working with adults with developmental disabilities
Molly: I identify as a white, female, who chronologically is 21 years old. However, this past year in social work has taught me more about the dimensions and definitions of "age". I am in a heterosexual partnership, but I am aware of how definite, molding, and limiting the labels of sexual orientation can be for an individual.
I was born and raised in Calgary AB, but have been a visitor in Victoria for three years. Needless to say I don't think I will be heading back to Calgary any time soon. I am in the middle of my third and fourth year in the Social Work program, which I am completing on-campus.
Claudia: I am a 25 year old, heterosexual female of Chinese decent. I was born in Canada but my parents had immigrated from Vietnam and China during the Vietnam war. I am just starting work in Child protection and have spent the last 2 years teaching English in Japan and Hong kong. It was a great learning experience about difference and accepting meanings and how things worked in various cultural contexts when I was there. It definitely brought to light the expectations that I had that WERE oppressive (expectations that people in other countries to understand English when many Americans and Canadians are not multilingual)
Razack emphasizes the sheer difficulty of understanding across differences and that there is the need for guidelines to listening. I think that to better listen to other voices, I need to accept ambiguity, ''pay attention to the interpretative structures we use to reconstruct events." and also of my multiple and fluid identities that are played out at one time (Razack, 1998)
Reference:
Razack, S. (1998). The Gaze from the Other Side: Storytelling for Social Change. In Looking White People in the Eye: Gender, Race, and Culture in Courtrooms and Classrooms. Toronto: University of Toronto Press. pp 36-55.
Introduction
Razack (1998) argues that we need to work from the basis that we all have partial knowledge; this does not mean we have to know and find all the answers, but rather be settled in the space of “not-knowing.” Communicating across difference can reaffirm the “other”; identity is reaffirmed because we define “who ‘we’ are because ‘we’ are not ‘them’” (Schick & St. Denis, 2005, pg. 389). It is important not to assume that we know what stories do or do not belong to which individuals, and to allow every person to share his or her own story because "all people have complex lives and...all have suffered injustice" (Curry-Stevens, p. 17). There is no 'other' - we are all connected in that we have all experienced oppression in some way (ibid).
The unit 3 readings encourage us to readdress how our own unearned privileges situate us in positions of dominance. It is important to consider how our positions of dominance allow us to take for granted what questions we have asked and who we have questioned. We need to settle in silence and resist the temptations to seek information through the lives of other individuals. bell hooks (1999) describes "the over-riding fear ... that cultural, ethnic, and racial differences will be continually commodified and offered up as new dishes to enhance the white palate—that the Other will be eaten, consumed, and forgotten" (p. 39). One must be concious of not consuming the stories of other individuals simply for the pleasure of consuming them.
What happens when someone tells or listens to a story?
This question is what introduces the third unit of the course, Communication and Language Issues in Education.
Ultimately, storytelling engenders multiple layers of meaning making because meanings will shift depending on who is listening; who is telling; and what context the story is being told in.
This unit makes one think about knowledge, and what and whose knowledge we choose to value. Why do we trust the weather report on the television rather than those individuals who claim their elbows get itchy when it is about to rain? Why has science and technology become the credible source?
The Unit notes describe storytelling as a way to “subvert official orthodoxies” (SOCW 452, course notes, 2011) and challenge conventional ways of thinking and knowing.
The language we use also represents how we make meaning; everything we say has an underlying assumption and meaning. Saying something as harmless as “I ran to the store”, suggests a lot about the individual’s capabilities, such as the ability to run, having the means to buy something, etc.
The unit notes also explore how meaning is connected to film images, which are not merely reflections of the truth, but are also means by which 'truth' is created as the viewer associates personal beliefs, values, etc. to the images.
How are professional identities formed through images? What meanings do we attribute to images of social workers? How do these images feed our sense of what makes a good social worker? “How does this engage our sense of fantasy or desire?” (SOCW 452, course notes, 2011).
References
hooks, b. (1992). Chapter 2. Eating the Other. Desire and Resistance. In Black Looks, Race and Representation (21-39). Toronto, ON: Between the Lines
Razack, S. (1998). The Gaze from the Other Side: Storytelling for Social Change. In Looking White People in the Eye: Gender, Race, and Culture in Courtrooms and Classrooms. Toronto: University of Toronto Press. pp 36-55.
Schick, C. & St. Denis, V. (2005). Criticial Autobigraphy in Integrative Anti-Racsit Pedagogy. In C.L Biggs and P.J. Downe (Eds.), Gendered Intersections: A Collection of Readings for Women's and Gender Studies. Halifax: Fernwood Press. pp. 387-392
Curry-Stevens, A. (2003) An Educator's Guide for Changing the World: Methods, Models and Materials for Anti-Oppression and Social Justice Workshops. http://www.socialjustice.org/index.php?page=peace-and-justice
Speaking for Others?
Alcoff reminds that the act of speaking or not speaking is itself not isolated. When we choose to speak or not speak, we are engaging in a social act. Therefore, when we consider speaking for others to be a problem, we must understand this problem to be a social one. Alcoff states, “the problem of speaking for others is a social one, the options cannot be understood as simply the results of autonomous individual choice” (1995, p. 101).
In order to understand the issue of speaking for others we must recognize that though it is impossible for any individual to claim a neutral voice, we can all claim a right and legitimacy to speak based on Alcoff’s first premise. The second premise proposed when struggling to come to terms with the issue of speaking for others is that some voices hold more power in society due to political and epistemological reasons.
Alcoff argues strongly against retreating from all practices that involve speaking for others, explaining that, “the claim that I can speak only for myself assumes the autonomous conception of the self... that I am unconnected to others in my authentic self of that I can achieve an autonomy from others given certain conditions”(1995, p. 108). But, according to Alcoff, this is impossible. Simply the act of choosing to speak or not to speak affects not only one’s lived experiences, but the experiences of others as well.
Despite arguing strongly against a general retreat from the act of speaking for others, Alcoff also makes notes as to why one must be cautious when doing so. He states that, “since no embodied speaker can produce more than a partial account, and since the process of producing meaning is necessarily collective, everyone’s account within a specified community need to be encouraged” (1995, p. 108). Alcoff believes that, by strongly analyzing power relations and possible effects to be had by speaking for others, we can reduce the possible harms. More specifically, we can reduce the chances of the oppression of marginalized voices by those dominant in society.
As education for social change "names and challenges ideas and practices that support inequality," we need to critically examine the act of speaking for others to ensure that they are not supporting inequality (Arnold, et. al., 1991, p. 41). The first principle argued by Alcoff is that, “the impetus to speak must be carefully analyzed and, in many cases…fought against” (1995, p. 111). The second involves recognizing the location and context in which one speaks. Third, speakers must always be held accountable and responsible for what they say. The last point mentioned by Alcoff is that there is a need to analyze probable outcomes that may result from speaking on another’s behalf.
In general, Alcoff argues that though one must be careful when speaking for others, the act must not be abandoned all together. The belief that we can retreat from “harming” others by refusing to speak for others is false. We live in a socially connected world where isolating one’s actions is nearly impossible.
Reference:
Alcoff, Linda Martin. (1995). The Problem of Speaking for Others. In Who Can Speak?: Authority and Critical Identity, J. Roof and R. Wiegman (Eds.). Illinois: University of Illinois: pp. 99-117
Arnold, Berke, James, et. al. (1991). Chapter 1. This is Our Chance: Educating Strategically, pp. 13-15. (Readings Package)
Video Clips: Speaking for Others
bell hooks (who describes herself as a "Black woman intellectual, revolutionary activist" http://www.shambhalasun.com/index.php?option=content&task=view&id=30&Itemid=161) discuses the representation of African American people by Hollywood, and discuses how ‘white’ Hollywood has taken on the role of creating movies for ‘black’ Americans, while filmmaker Spike Lee’s work is not recognized as being a valid representation of African American culture.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VEQh-Zpb4XU
This second clip is a speech entitled ‘From Noble Savage to Righteous Warrior’, by Taiaike Alfred, “a Mohawk author, consultant, and teacher of Indigenous knowledge and history” (http://taiaiake.posterous.com/). In this clip, he speaks to how Indigenous people's identity has been impacted by the colonizer's representation of Indigenous culture. The entire clip is one hour and well worth watching, but the particular comments around who gets to tell Indigenous people’s story, and how Indigenous people are represented are from the 10 – 16 minute section of the clip.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8ZfGAqdIJmE
After watching the clips, please share your thoughts around the following:
• What are the implications of speaking on behalf of another individual or group?
• What are some potential ‘benefits’ (to the oppressor) of speaking for others?
• How has your understanding of ‘speaking for others’ changed?
• What impact does popular culture have on who is spoken about, and how they are represented?
• How would these messages be different if the speaker(s) was caucasian?
References:
Alfred, T. (2010). From noble savage to righteous warrior. Retrieved June 4th, 2011 from http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8ZfGAqdIJmE
Alfred, T. (2011) Retrieved June 6th 2011 from http://taiaiake.posterous.com/
hooks, b. (2011). Cultural critique (Spike Lee). Retrieved June 4th, 2011, from http://www.viddler.com/explore/shadowandact/videos/252/
Image of the Social Worker
Story telling is a means to share our own perspective of an experience with those whom we are telling the story to. It is a way to transform our private experience into public meanings so that we can make sense of it. As social workers who are within the circle of social work education, we profess to follow the ethics of the BCASW and following supporting clients in advocacy, gaining their rights and resources etc. Story-telling and personal experience has been a core value of social work practice to help clients and ourselves “make meaning” through narrating significant experiences. It gives an individual voice and power to share their experience when they are heard. Recently education has turned to narrative approaches to develop critical reflection and self awareness. (Harrison, 755)
In Harrison’s article, the process of tutorials for students to reflect on their practicum through storytelling to their fellow students is studied and recorded. The tutorial becomes a space for students to discuss, reflect and question their recollections. One of these stories reflects the question of how social work education produces the idea of what a “good social worker” entails. The article provides a story from one of the students who spoke of a colleagues actions in their personal life that ran contrary to the principles of practice for social workers. ( She would not allow her grandfather who was in a wheelchair to come to her wedding, because she felt the wheelchair would spoil her photographs) Her actions directly counters cultural norms that families should be included in these celebrations as well as social work ethics that promotes autonomy and inclusiveness, thus questions her moral and professional integrity.
How are we presented and taught in education? “If we accept that the requirements of social work role includes ‘the ability to demonstrate a virtuous character’ (Harrison, 758 retained from Clark, 2006, 75)….to reconcile the declared ethics of the profession with the apparent ethics of the person. “In training and education of qualifying practitioners, it is important not to overlook the expectation that we produce the ‘right kind of person’. ( Harrison, 763) I thought that this was interesting about the way that our social education presents perhaps the “type” of person that social workers should be.
In social work, is there a difference between the personal and the professional self? Should how we behave in our personal life be separated from the professional?
References:
Harrison, Kaeren. “’Listen: This Really Happened’: Making Sense of Social Work through Story-telling.” Social Work Education. 2009. Vol 28 Issue 7. P 750-764.