Tuesday, June 7, 2011

Introduction

Why do we ask questions? What engenders our curiosity? Why do we need to know?

Razack (1998) argues that we need to work from the basis that we all have partial knowledge; this does not mean we have to know and find all the answers, but rather be settled in the space of “not-knowing.” Communicating across difference can reaffirm the “other”; identity is reaffirmed because we define “who ‘we’ are because ‘we’ are not ‘them’” (Schick & St. Denis, 2005, pg. 389). It is important not to assume that we know what stories do or do not belong to which individuals, and to allow every person to share his or her own story because "all people have complex lives and...all have suffered injustice" (Curry-Stevens, p. 17). There is no 'other' - we are all connected in that we have all experienced oppression in some way (ibid).

The unit 3 readings encourage us to readdress how our own unearned privileges situate us in positions of dominance. It is important to consider how our positions of dominance allow us to take for granted what questions we have asked and who we have questioned. We need to settle in silence and resist the temptations to seek information through the lives of other individuals. bell hooks (1999) describes "the over-riding fear ... that cultural, ethnic, and racial differences will be continually commodified and offered up as new dishes to enhance the white palate—that the Other will be eaten, consumed, and forgotten" (p. 39). One must be concious of not consuming the stories of other individuals simply for the pleasure of consuming them.



What happens when someone tells or listens to a story?

This question is what introduces the third unit of the course, Communication and Language Issues in Education.

Ultimately, storytelling engenders multiple layers of meaning making because meanings will shift depending on who is listening; who is telling; and what context the story is being told in.

This unit makes one think about knowledge, and what and whose knowledge we choose to value. Why do we trust the weather report on the television rather than those individuals who claim their elbows get itchy when it is about to rain? Why has science and technology become the credible source?

The Unit notes describe storytelling as a way to “subvert official orthodoxies” (SOCW 452, course notes, 2011) and challenge conventional ways of thinking and knowing.

The language we use also represents how we make meaning; everything we say has an underlying assumption and meaning. Saying something as harmless as “I ran to the store”, suggests a lot about the individual’s capabilities, such as the ability to run, having the means to buy something, etc.
The unit notes also explore how meaning is connected to film images, which are not merely reflections of the truth, but are also means by which 'truth' is created as the viewer associates personal beliefs, values, etc. to the images.
How are professional identities formed through images? What meanings do we attribute to images of social workers? How do these images feed our sense of what makes a good social worker? “How does this engage our sense of fantasy or desire?” (SOCW 452, course notes, 2011).

References
hooks, b. (1992). Chapter 2. Eating the Other. Desire and Resistance. In Black Looks, Race and Representation (21-39). Toronto, ON: Between the Lines
Razack, S. (1998). The Gaze from the Other Side: Storytelling for Social Change. In Looking White People in the Eye: Gender, Race, and Culture in Courtrooms and Classrooms. Toronto: University of Toronto Press. pp 36-55.
Schick, C. & St. Denis, V. (2005). Criticial Autobigraphy in Integrative Anti-Racsit Pedagogy. In C.L Biggs and P.J. Downe (Eds.), Gendered Intersections: A Collection of Readings for Women's and Gender Studies. Halifax: Fernwood Press. pp. 387-392
Curry-Stevens, A. (2003) An Educator's Guide for Changing the World: Methods, Models and Materials for Anti-Oppression and Social Justice Workshops. http://www.socialjustice.org/index.php?page=peace-and-justice

No comments:

Post a Comment