In the article, The Problem of Speaking for Others, Alcoff (1995) recognizes that there is no easy solution towards coming to terms with whether or not it is beneficial to speak for others. He argues that ultimately, one should not be afraid of speaking for others, but rather, when doing so, one should be careful and aware of the possible results of this act.
Alcoff reminds that the act of speaking or not speaking is itself not isolated. When we choose to speak or not speak, we are engaging in a social act. Therefore, when we consider speaking for others to be a problem, we must understand this problem to be a social one. Alcoff states, “the problem of speaking for others is a social one, the options cannot be understood as simply the results of autonomous individual choice” (1995, p. 101).
In order to understand the issue of speaking for others we must recognize that though it is impossible for any individual to claim a neutral voice, we can all claim a right and legitimacy to speak based on Alcoff’s first premise. The second premise proposed when struggling to come to terms with the issue of speaking for others is that some voices hold more power in society due to political and epistemological reasons.
Alcoff argues strongly against retreating from all practices that involve speaking for others, explaining that, “the claim that I can speak only for myself assumes the autonomous conception of the self... that I am unconnected to others in my authentic self of that I can achieve an autonomy from others given certain conditions”(1995, p. 108). But, according to Alcoff, this is impossible. Simply the act of choosing to speak or not to speak affects not only one’s lived experiences, but the experiences of others as well.
Despite arguing strongly against a general retreat from the act of speaking for others, Alcoff also makes notes as to why one must be cautious when doing so. He states that, “since no embodied speaker can produce more than a partial account, and since the process of producing meaning is necessarily collective, everyone’s account within a specified community need to be encouraged” (1995, p. 108). Alcoff believes that, by strongly analyzing power relations and possible effects to be had by speaking for others, we can reduce the possible harms. More specifically, we can reduce the chances of the oppression of marginalized voices by those dominant in society.
As education for social change "names and challenges ideas and practices that support inequality," we need to critically examine the act of speaking for others to ensure that they are not supporting inequality (Arnold, et. al., 1991, p. 41). The first principle argued by Alcoff is that, “the impetus to speak must be carefully analyzed and, in many cases…fought against” (1995, p. 111). The second involves recognizing the location and context in which one speaks. Third, speakers must always be held accountable and responsible for what they say. The last point mentioned by Alcoff is that there is a need to analyze probable outcomes that may result from speaking on another’s behalf.
In general, Alcoff argues that though one must be careful when speaking for others, the act must not be abandoned all together. The belief that we can retreat from “harming” others by refusing to speak for others is false. We live in a socially connected world where isolating one’s actions is nearly impossible.
Reference:
Alcoff, Linda Martin. (1995). The Problem of Speaking for Others. In Who Can Speak?: Authority and Critical Identity, J. Roof and R. Wiegman (Eds.). Illinois: University of Illinois: pp. 99-117
Arnold, Berke, James, et. al. (1991). Chapter 1. This is Our Chance: Educating Strategically, pp. 13-15. (Readings Package)
No comments:
Post a Comment